Return of the king

Category: Cinema 31

Post 1 by Wishes (Veteran Zoner) on Thursday, 09-Sep-2004 18:05:10

So, here's the motion, The Return Of The King is the worst movie ever made. Why?

1. Overhyped, over-the-top, ill conceived script
2. Bad CGI
3. Bad acting
4. Rubbish editing

Post 2 by DarkMetalChangeling (Account disabled) on Thursday, 09-Sep-2004 18:57:39

Certainly it was the weakest of the 3 films, with the post victory part a bit messy. Too much emphasis on the Battle of the Pelenor fields where they could of made so much more of other strong parts of the story like the paths of the dead! Not a bad effort, but could have done a lot better!

Post 3 by Goblin (I have proven to myself and the world that I need mental help) on Sunday, 19-Sep-2004 7:13:48

What were you watching a badly cobbled together pirate copy of a 3rd rate dodgy dvd hurridly put together in a filthy
9yr old's bedroom

ROTK is genuis the battle scenes are expertly filmed to put you in the thick of the action.
The struggle of Sam & Frodo is touching without being cloying and you really see the extent to which Sam's character has grown.

Frodo's transformation is brilliantly portrayed by Elijah Wood no one else could have played that character.

Hail Peter Jackson!